om:89-cl-2020-july — Due to certain circumstances prevailing, Applicant who was a Reservation Supervisor in East Coast Railway at Waltair Division, requested for mutual transfer with one Shri P. Rajeev who was a Reservation Supervisor-II at Chakradharpur Division on the ground of the illness of his father. His substitute had joined Waltair Division from Chakradharpur Division. Hence cancellation of Applicant's transfer to Chakradharpur Division is not possible. Hence Applicant should carry out his transfer to Chakra

Due to certain circumstances prevailing, Applicant who was a Reservation Supervisor in East Coast Railway at Waltair Division, requested for mutual transfer with one Shri P. Rajeev who was a Reservation Supervisor-II at Chakradharpur Division on the ground of the illness of his father. His substitute had joined Waltair Division from Chakradharpur Division. Hence cancellation of Applicant's transfer to Chakradharpur Division is not possible. Hence Applicant should carry out his transfer to Chakradharpur Division but Respondents should not take any action on the Applicant for his request for retaining him at Waltair Division. — The given chunk is about a case (O.A. No. 496 with M.A. No. 587 of 2019) involving an Applicant, who was a Reservation Supervisor in East Coast Railway at Waltair Division, requesting for mutual tran... — Facts : Applicant who joined as Enquiry-cum-Reservation Clerk under Senior Divisional Commercial Manager, Waltair Division, R-4 herein, was promoted as Reservation Supervisor. Applicant submitted a representation for mutual transfer with one Shri P. Rajeev, Reservation Supervisor, East Coast Railway, Chakradharpur Division, R-6 herein, which was accepted. But due to change of circumstances, Applicant prayed for retention at Waltair Division cancelling his mutual transfer. Tribunal heard both sides and held: