UPSC Editorial Analysis: Acid Attacks in India
Kartavya Desk Staff
*General Studies-1; Topic: **Salient features of Indian Society*
Introduction
• Acid attacks are a particularly heinous form of gender-based violence, intended not just to physically harm but to permanently disfigure, isolate, and inflict lifelong psychological trauma on the victim.
• Despite the introduction of stringent laws following the 2013 Justice Verma Committee report, the criminal justice system has struggled to deter these crimes.
• Recently, a Supreme Court bench termed the delay in justice for these victims a “matter of deep shame,” highlighting a systemic failure to protect women.
About Acid Attacks in India
• Acid attacks in India remain a grave concern due to high court pendency (88%) and poor conviction rates. Despite strict laws, regulatory failures and patriarchal mindsets deny survivors timely justice and rehabilitation.
Current Status and Data Analysis (NCRB 2023)
To understand the magnitude of the crisis, we must look at the latest official statistics and judicial observations.
• Prevalence: According to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), there were 207 reported cases of acid attacks in 2023. Experts argue that actual figures are likely higher due to underreporting in rural areas where stigma prevents families from approaching the police.
• According to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), there were 207 reported cases of acid attacks in 2023. Experts argue that actual figures are likely higher due to underreporting in rural areas where stigma prevents families from approaching the police.
• Regional Hotspots: The states of West Bengal, Uttar Pradesh, and Gujarat reported the highest number of incidents.
• The states of West Bengal, Uttar Pradesh, and Gujarat reported the highest number of incidents.
• Judicial Backlog: The most alarming statistic is the pendency rate. Nearly 88% of acid attack cases remain pending in courts. Out of 735 cases slated for trial, 649 have been stuck in the legal system for years.
• The most alarming statistic is the pendency rate. Nearly 88% of acid attack cases remain pending in courts. Out of 735 cases slated for trial, 649 have been stuck in the legal system for years.
• Case Study of Delay: The Supreme Court highlighted a specific case where a victim has been awaiting a verdict for 16 years, demonstrating the lethargy of the legal process.
• The Supreme Court highlighted a specific case where a victim has been awaiting a verdict for 16 years, demonstrating the lethargy of the legal process.
The Social Dimension: Patriarchy and Rejection
• Root Cause: Research indicates that the majority of attacks stem from a rejection of marriage proposals or resistance to sexual advances. This reflects a deep-seated patriarchal mindset where a woman is viewed as property; disfigurement is used as a tool to “devalue” her.
• Research indicates that the majority of attacks stem from a rejection of marriage proposals or resistance to sexual advances. This reflects a deep-seated patriarchal mindset where a woman is viewed as property; disfigurement is used as a tool to “devalue” her.
• Social Ostracization: Unlike other survivors of violence, acid attack survivors carry visible scars. This often leads to social withdrawal, difficulty in finding employment, and even abandonment by families who view the survivor as a “burden.”
• Unlike other survivors of violence, acid attack survivors carry visible scars. This often leads to social withdrawal, difficulty in finding employment, and even abandonment by families who view the survivor as a “burden.”
• Psychological Toll: The trauma is profound and lifelong, often leading to severe depression, anxiety, and in some tragic instances, suicide.
• The trauma is profound and lifelong, often leading to severe depression, anxiety, and in some tragic instances, suicide.
The Legal Dimension: Legislation vs. Execution
• Legal Framework: The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013, introduced specific sections in the Indian Penal Code (IPC): Section 326A: Punishes voluntarily causing grievous hurt by use of acid with a minimum of 10 years imprisonment (extendable to life) and a fine aimed at victim medical expenses. Section 326B: Punishes the attempt to throw acid with a minimum of 5 years imprisonment.
• The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013, introduced specific sections in the Indian Penal Code (IPC): Section 326A: Punishes voluntarily causing grievous hurt by use of acid with a minimum of 10 years imprisonment (extendable to life) and a fine aimed at victim medical expenses. Section 326B: Punishes the attempt to throw acid with a minimum of 5 years imprisonment.
• Section 326A: Punishes voluntarily causing grievous hurt by use of acid with a minimum of 10 years imprisonment (extendable to life) and a fine aimed at victim medical expenses.
• Section 326B: Punishes the attempt to throw acid with a minimum of 5 years imprisonment.
• Implementation Gap: Despite these laws, conviction rates are low. The Supreme Court observed that the brutality of these crimes often warrants punishment even more stringent than the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), yet the slow pace of trials dilutes the deterrence factor.
• Despite these laws, conviction rates are low. The Supreme Court observed that the brutality of these crimes often warrants punishment even more stringent than the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), yet the slow pace of trials dilutes the deterrence factor.
• New Forms of Brutality: The Court noted cases where victims were forcibly made to ingest acid, causing severe internal injuries. Current laws sometimes struggle to address the specific medical complexities of internal burns compared to external disfigurement.
• The Court noted cases where victims were forcibly made to ingest acid, causing severe internal injuries. Current laws sometimes struggle to address the specific medical complexities of internal burns compared to external disfigurement.
The Medical and Rehabilitation Dimension
• Treatment Costs: Acid burns require immediate, specialized, and often expensive medical care, including multiple reconstructive (plastic) surgeries.
• Acid burns require immediate, specialized, and often expensive medical care, including multiple reconstructive (plastic) surgeries.
• Lack of Free Care: Currently, there is no comprehensive legal provision ensuring free, long-term medical treatment and rehabilitation for survivors.
• Currently, there is no comprehensive legal provision ensuring free, long-term medical treatment and rehabilitation for survivors.
• Demand for Private Sector Inclusion: There is a strong demand for the government to mandate and facilitate free treatment in private hospitals as well, given that specialized burn units are not always available in government facilities.
• There is a strong demand for the government to mandate and facilitate free treatment in private hospitals as well, given that specialized burn units are not always available in government facilities.
The Governance Dimension: Regulation of Acid Sales
• Laxmi v. Union of India (2014): In this landmark judgment, the Supreme Court imposed restrictions on the over-the-counter sale of acid. It mandated that sellers maintain a register of buyers and that buyers provide ID proof and a reason for purchase.
• In this landmark judgment, the Supreme Court imposed restrictions on the over-the-counter sale of acid. It mandated that sellers maintain a register of buyers and that buyers provide ID proof and a reason for purchase.
• Regulatory Failure: These guidelines are routinely violated. Acid remains easily accessible in local markets for domestic cleaning, serving as a cheap and lethal weapon. The Supreme Court noted that these rules are “observed in the breach.”
• These guidelines are routinely violated. Acid remains easily accessible in local markets for domestic cleaning, serving as a cheap and lethal weapon. The Supreme Court noted that these rules are “observed in the breach.”
Recent Supreme Court Directives
To address these failures, the Supreme Court has issued new, urgent directives:
• Data on Pendency: Registrars of High Courts must provide details of all pending acid attack trials to the Supreme Court within four weeks.
• Registrars of High Courts must provide details of all pending acid attack trials to the Supreme Court within four weeks.
• Legal Amendments: The Solicitor General has been asked to propose amendments to the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016. This is to ensuring that acid attack survivors (especially those with internal injuries) are clearly categorized to receive statutory disability benefits.
• The Solicitor General has been asked to propose amendments to the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016. This is to ensuring that acid attack survivors (especially those with internal injuries) are clearly categorized to receive statutory disability benefits.
• Special Courts: The Court proposed setting up Special Courts to conduct trials on a day-to-day basis, bypassing the clogged regular court system.
• The Court proposed setting up Special Courts to conduct trials on a day-to-day basis, bypassing the clogged regular court system.
Challenges in the System
• Investigative Delays: Police frequently delay filing charge sheets, and forensic evidence collection is often mishandled.
• Police frequently delay filing charge sheets, and forensic evidence collection is often mishandled.
• Witness Intimidation: Long trials (e.g., 16 years) allow accused persons out on bail to intimidate witnesses, leading them to turn hostile.
• Long trials (e.g., 16 years) allow accused persons out on bail to intimidate witnesses, leading them to turn hostile.
• Compensation Issues: While the Victim Compensation Scheme exists (Section 357A CrPC), the disbursement is often slow, bureaucratic, and insufficient to cover the high costs of private medical care.
• While the Victim Compensation Scheme exists (Section 357A CrPC), the disbursement is often slow, bureaucratic, and insufficient to cover the high costs of private medical care.
Way Forward
• Fast-Track Mechanisms: The establishment of Special Courts for daily hearings is essential to clear the backlog and restore faith in the judiciary.
• The establishment of Special Courts for daily hearings is essential to clear the backlog and restore faith in the judiciary.
• Strict Supply Chain Control: The sale of acid should be digitized and tracked, similar to the sale of poisons. A complete ban on the retail sale of concentrated acid for domestic use should be considered, replacing it with safer alternatives.
• The sale of acid should be digitized and tracked, similar to the sale of poisons. A complete ban on the retail sale of concentrated acid for domestic use should be considered, replacing it with safer alternatives.
• Comprehensive Rehabilitation Law: A specific law is needed that guarantees 100% state-funded medical care in any hospital (public or private) and provides a monthly pension or guaranteed government employment for survivors to ensure their economic independence.
• A specific law is needed that guarantees 100% state-funded medical care in any hospital (public or private) and provides a monthly pension or guaranteed government employment for survivors to ensure their economic independence.
• Societal Sensitization: Long-term change requires moral education and awareness campaigns to dismantle the patriarchal entitlement that fuels gender-based violence.
• Long-term change requires moral education and awareness campaigns to dismantle the patriarchal entitlement that fuels gender-based violence.
Conclusion
• The systemic failure in addressing acid attacks demands urgent correction. True justice requires fast-track courts, strict regulation of acid sales, and holistic rehabilitation to restore the dignity and constitutional rights of survivors.
What is the law on acid attacks in India? – INSIGHTS IAS – Simplifying UPSC IAS Exam Preparation