President’s Rule is often criticized for weakening the principles of cooperative federalism. Do you agree? Substantiate your answer with relevant examples.
Kartavya Desk Staff
Topic: Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure,
Topic: Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure,
Q3. President’s Rule is often criticized for weakening the principles of cooperative federalism. Do you agree? Substantiate your answer with relevant examples. (10 M)
Difficulty Level: Medium
Reference: IE
Why the question President’s rule among options being considered if no agreement or consensus is reached in Manipur: Key demand of the question The question demands a critical analysis of how President’s Rule weakens cooperative federalism, along with a counterview highlighting its necessity in certain situations. A balanced conclusion is required. Structure of the answer Introduction: Briefly define President’s Rule (Article 356) and its significance in Indian federalism. Mention its dual nature—restoring constitutional order but also prone to misuse. Body: How President’s Rule weakens cooperative federalism – Discuss how it centralizes power, disregards state autonomy, affects governance continuity, and has been politically misused. Counterview: When President’s Rule is necessary – Highlight situations where it ensures constitutional governance, restores law and order, and prevents instability. Conclusion: Emphasize that President’s Rule should be an exception, not a norm. Suggest strengthening constitutional safeguards to uphold federal principles while ensuring governance stability.
Why the question
President’s rule among options being considered if no agreement or consensus is reached in Manipur:
Key demand of the question
The question demands a critical analysis of how President’s Rule weakens cooperative federalism, along with a counterview highlighting its necessity in certain situations. A balanced conclusion is required.
Structure of the answer
Introduction:
Briefly define President’s Rule (Article 356) and its significance in Indian federalism. Mention its dual nature—restoring constitutional order but also prone to misuse.
• How President’s Rule weakens cooperative federalism – Discuss how it centralizes power, disregards state autonomy, affects governance continuity, and has been politically misused.
• Counterview: When President’s Rule is necessary – Highlight situations where it ensures constitutional governance, restores law and order, and prevents instability.
Conclusion:
Emphasize that President’s Rule should be an exception, not a norm. Suggest strengthening constitutional safeguards to uphold federal principles while ensuring governance stability.