Discuss the evolution of principle of creamy layer in the process of reservation. What are the challenges associated with it? Suggest measures.
Kartavya Desk Staff
Topic: Welfare schemes for Vulnerable sections
Topic: Welfare schemes for Vulnerable sections
Q4. Discuss the evolution of principle of creamy layer in the process of reservation. What are the challenges associated with it? Suggest measures. (15M)
- •*Difficulty level: Moderate
- •Reference: The Hindu*
Why the question: The allotment of Indian Administrative Service (IAS) to Puja Khedkar as an Other Backward Class (OBC) Non-Creamy Layer (NCL) candidate coupled has raised issues surrounding the creamy layer in OBC reservation. Key Demand of the Question: Discuss the evolution of the “creamy layer” principle in reservation, identify associated challenges, and suggest measures to address these challenges. Directive: Discuss – This requires an examination of the development of the creamy layer principle, an analysis of its challenges, and proposals for improvements. Structure of the answer: Introduction: Define the principle of “creamy layer” and its origin in the reservation process. Body: First part: Evolution of the Principle Historical context and introduction by the Mandal Commission. Supreme Court rulings on the creamy layer (e.g., Indra Sawhney case). Recent developments and application in reservation policies. Second part: Challenges Associated with the Creamy Layer Difficulty in accurate identification and exclusion. Inconsistency in implementation across states. Discontent among less privileged members within OBCs. Third part: Measures to Address Challenges Standardising criteria and processes for creamy layer identification. Regular reviews and updates of creamy layer definitions. Enhanced transparency and awareness about the reservation process. Conclusion: Emphasize the need for reforms to ensure equitable and effective reservation policies.
Why the question:
The allotment of Indian Administrative Service (IAS) to Puja Khedkar as an Other Backward Class (OBC) Non-Creamy Layer (NCL) candidate coupled has raised issues surrounding the creamy layer in OBC reservation.
Key Demand of the Question:
Discuss the evolution of the “creamy layer” principle in reservation, identify associated challenges, and suggest measures to address these challenges.
Directive:
Discuss – This requires an examination of the development of the creamy layer principle, an analysis of its challenges, and proposals for improvements.
Structure of the answer:
Introduction:
Define the principle of “creamy layer” and its origin in the reservation process.
First part: Evolution of the Principle
Historical context and introduction by the Mandal Commission.
Supreme Court rulings on the creamy layer (e.g., Indra Sawhney case).
Recent developments and application in reservation policies.
Second part: Challenges Associated with the Creamy Layer
Difficulty in accurate identification and exclusion.
Inconsistency in implementation across states.
Discontent among less privileged members within OBCs.
Third part: Measures to Address Challenges
Standardising criteria and processes for creamy layer identification.
Regular reviews and updates of creamy layer definitions.
Enhanced transparency and awareness about the reservation process.
Conclusion:
Emphasize the need for reforms to ensure equitable and effective reservation policies.